Green energy transition sparks concerns of mass layoffs despite Biden’s billions
Experts caution that the United States ambitious shift toward cleaner energy sources is accompanied by the looming threat of widespread job losses in established industries, with doubts raised about the effectiveness of policies aimed at mitigating the economic impact.
The Biden administration, championing its 2022 Inflation Reduction Act, emphasizes financial support amounting to billions of dollars targeted at communities adversely affected by the energy transition.
However, skeptics argue that the touted measures may fall short of their promises.
A significant milestone was reached at the UN-led COP28 summit in Dubai, where participating governments endorsed an agreement favoring the “just, orderly, and equitable” transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems.
Under the Biden program, substantial funding is allocated to projects in regions grappling with the decline of coal mining jobs.
This includes billions for facilitating the conversion of manufacturing infrastructure, encompassing everything from internal combustion engine (ICE) auto plants to oil refineries, in a bid to ensure a smooth transition to electric vehicles and the preservation of high-quality jobs.
Critics, such as Harvard’s Professor Gordon Hanson, express skepticism, predicting that the policies might be more successful in boosting green output than in safeguarding workers from declining industries.
Concerns intensify over potential mass layoffs, particularly from the closure of ICE assembly plants or oil refineries, potentially resulting in the loss of two to three million jobs over the next 15 years.
Despite the promising aspects of the Department of Energy’s funding initiatives, not everyone is convinced. Hanson underscores the need for a disruptive plan to address the potential fallout, drawing parallels to the impact of globalization and technological innovation on manufacturing in past decades.
On November 27, the Department of Energy unveiled a $275 million funding package for seven projects targeting regions affected by coal mine or coal-fired power plant closures.
Noteworthy recipients include Alpen High Performance Products, utilizing funds to enhance production capabilities in response to growing demand for energy-efficient materials.
While Alpen’s CEO, Brad Begin, anticipates adding jobs due to increased demand, concerns linger about the broader workforce.
The transition from “dirty” jobs to “green” jobs remains challenging, as highlighted by a July 2023 study from the National Bureau of Economic Research, indicating that less than one percent of workers leaving “dirty jobs” secure positions in the “green” sector.
Economist E. Mark Curtis acknowledges the challenges, particularly for older workers and those lacking a college degree.
Harvard’s Hanson proposes a separate policy targeting vulnerable workers and suggests increased spending on community colleges, additional unemployment benefits for affected communities, and encouragement of small business loans in hard-hit regions.
As the nation navigates this complex transition, balancing environmental goals with economic consequences becomes an increasingly intricate challenge.
About The Author
